Sweden's election on Sunday
- conservative sweep in a socialist land?
Associate since 1991
Comments directly to
January 19, 2010
Is the state an opponent? I put this question to a top Gothenburg lawyer, Christina Ramberg, when interviewing her about Sweden and its top heavy welfare state. “No it's a friend”, she replies, although she never votes for the Socialists. Alexandra von Schwerin, an aristocratic businesswoman paying very high taxes, says “No, it's a father.”
Not even Prime Minister Fredrik Reinfeldt, leader of a right wing coalition that four years ago replaced the habitual governing party, the Social Democrats, is much against the state. He has dropped the old right wing mantra of calling for lowering taxes and wants to see only “a more efficient and less conformist state and society”. In an interview he told me that “we are not asking for a different system, just for better results.”
The sense of equality goes deep down in the Swedish psyche, he explains. “The Swedish electorate don't always look at their wallet. They do want to see other people better off, as well as themselves”.
I asked him where did this unusually benign development in human nature come from- the Church, politics, or where exactly? Some part religion, he answered, “Although hardly anyone goes to church these days and we have no link to God the basic ideas of Christianity stayed on.” He also pointed to the fact that Sweden has avoided war for 200 years, so it has long been able to benefit from economic growth. “Because of that we had the wherewithal to develop the welfare state in the 1950s. In fact in the 50s we all thought it was a happy time. We had a deeply felt feeling we can afford it.”
In the late 1970s Sweden began to lose its economic momentum. The right wing parties came into government for the first time in years and there were severe cutbacks in social services. Their pairing back, tax cuts and famous bank rescue (that the US and the UK have partly modelled their recent bank resuscitation on) did help to re-float Sweden. But it only made the electorate nostalgic for the Social Democrats.
Under the self confident socialist and economically skilled prime minister, Goran Persson, Sweden stormed back into the fight- producing annual per head growth rates year after year that were the highest among the larger Western countries (They still are). The social services began to be restored- but not to their former glory.
Sclerosis of the system had set in - a more bureaucratic health and welfare service. A senior local politician, Tove Klette, tells me that in the old people's homes of Lund, a prosperous university town just across the bridge from Copenhagen, 47% of the time of the staff is spent in administration. It is the same in the hospitals. In the not so distant past people felt entitled to sick leave, even if it is just to watch an important football match. Holidays are regular and long- in the summer stretching to five weeks.
Still the economy has purred on. Swedes are simply extraordinarily efficient and use their time at work very well. “When we work”, says Professor Ramberg, “We work very well, even without the boss pushing us. No one here could write a book like that French woman a couple of years ago on how not to work at work."The prime minister added, “If a plumber says he'll come to your home at 7am he'll be there at 7, and do the job fast and to a high standard.”
Swedes are the Japanese of Europe, I've concluded, an observation that the prime minister doesn't demur from. Swedes are conformists, by temperament. It is hard to break out and become a highly successful individual, head and shoulders above everyone else. Of course, this isn't universal or otherwise there'd be no Swedish Ericsson, Tetrapak, Electrolux or Volvo, but it's the going ethos.
The conservative government has been trying to loosen up the conformism of Swedish society, destroying monopolies, introducing competition in the health services and schools and removing petty rules. “We want individual life to flourish, with a much greater degree of freedom”, says Mr Reinfeldt.
I see the conformism on a small scale in Lund. A few years ago cafes had no outside tables. Then, copying what Swedes had seen on southern holidays, they started putting them out. But the town council stepped in and said they must all be dismantled by September 30th. Now they are allowed to be there all year round.
Sweden seems to be finding a balance to its basic socialist ethos. Probity, self discipline and high productivity define the market place. But breaking apart the “Japanese” mentality is now a widely accepted social goal. It is not sprinting yet. But if this government wins a second term on Sunday, as is most likely, it will doubtless accelerate the pace to bringing about a less conformist and parochial Sweden..
Copyright © 2010 Jonathan
Jonathan Power can be
reached by phone +44 7785 351172
and e-mail: JonatPower@aol.com
The Quest for Global Justice
of Humanity” poses eleven questions for our future progress, ranging
from “Can we diminish War?” to “How far and fast can
we push forward the frontiers of Human Rights?” to “Will
China dominate the century?”
The answers to these questions, the author believes, growing out of
his long experience as a foreign correspondent and columnist for the
International Herald Tribune, are largely positive ones, despite the
hurdles yet to be overcome. Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, London, 2007.
William Pfaff, September 17, 2007
Jonathan Power's book "Conundrums" - A Review
"His is a powerful and comprehensive statement of ways to make the world better.
Is that worth the Nobel Prize?
I say, why not?"
Tell a friend about this column by Jonathan Power
Message and your name
free articles & updates