TFF logoFORUMS Power Columns

TFF Home | About us


Iraq Forum

Features by others

Links to all issues

New stuff

Other associate articles

Burundi Forum

Publications on-line

Paul McCartney

Nyt på nordisk

Jonathan Power

EU conflict-handling

The 100 best books

Annual Reports

TFF Associates


Reconciliation project

Øbergs Kalejdoskop

Support TFF on-line

Activities right now

Gandhi & India

Teaching & training

Oberg's photos

Support TFF off-line

PressInfos - Analyses

Macedonia Forum

Lærestof på dansk

TFF News Navigator


Beslan and the crude instinct
of solving problems by warfare



Jonathan Power
TFF Associate since 1991

September 8, 2004


'We showed weakness and weak people are beaten,' said President Vladimir Putin after surveying the wreckage of the battle scarred school in Beslan. Now we know what President George W. Bush meant when he said after his first meeting with Putin that he had looked into his eyes and had seen his soul. He had indeed found a soul mate. The meek, they both believe, shall not inherit the earth.

Who fights with Dragons, said Nietzsche, shall himself become a dragon. But the other horn of the dilemma is he who does not fight with dragons may be devoured by them.

War is sometimes perhaps necessary. But in too many cases it degrades the fighter and his cause. The resort to force is too often crudely instinctive, as in Iraq despite the thinness of the arguments for war. In this latest case the lack of sophistication of the Russian troops, first in Chechnya and now, horribly, with their mad, undisciplined, rush to free the children, has allowed animal instincts to overcome all rational behavior. Yet for all that war in the world is diminishing.

Undoubtedly the European Union's greatest achievement has been to cement the warring nations of Europe into a peaceful whole. Most recently the lure of Europe has compelled the Turks, after years of savage warfare, to parley with the Kurds in a way that Russia could do well to emulate with the Chechnyans.

For the first time in history a not insignificant number of states have been free from war for the best part of two centuries. In Europe there are Sweden and Switzerland, both despite a long tradition of warfare. In Latin America, Venezuela, Costa Rica and Brazil have now lived out a century without war. Indeed, entire regions of our planet have escaped internal war for over a century- North America most importantly. Neither Canada, Mexico nor the U.S. maintains troops on each other's borders. Likewise the South Pacific has long been peaceful, apart from a brief invasion by the Japanese in the Second World War and by relatively small-scale conflicts in West Iranian and East Timor.

Would you be reading this now,
if it wasn't useful to you?
Get more quality articles in the future

Looking back over a vast historical panorama, Oxford historian Evan Luard, in his meticulous book on the history of war, showed that overtime wars have become less frequent and the number of years in which an average country has been involved in war has declined over the centuries. He also showed that we see from our modern perspective that the reasons wars were fought were not issues that would now engage most of us. Would we fight to keep our prince in power? Would we fight for our tribe (unless we were Basques, Serbs or Ulstermen)? Most of us certainly wouldn't fight for our religion and it is extremely doubtful if we would fight to expand the territory of our country.

Putin seems to have taken a leap backward into a history that has now moved on for most nations. The biography of Mikhail Gorbachev by another Oxford don, Archie Brown, reveals not one mention of Chechnya, and that Gorbachev when faced with insurrection in the Baltic States withstood the formidable pressure from the Soviet military to wield the big stick. It was Boris Yeltsin who made the decision to unravel everything that Moscow had learnt from its war in Afghanistan and unleashed the dogs of war in Chechnya. But to its credit the Yeltsin administration arrived at peaceful power sharing agreements with restless Tatarstan, Bashkiria and forty other regions. This latter fact reflected a trend that was worldwide. Between 1993 and 2001 the number of wars of self-determination was halved. During the 1990s sixteen separatist wars were settled by peace agreements and ten others were checked by ceasefires and negotiation, according to the Minority at Risk Project of the University of Maryland.

War, the systematic and organized use of violence with all its bestial destructiveness, is peculiar to the most advanced of animals, man. Writing in the sixteenth century the Dutch philosopher Erasmus considered wars 'Whoever heard of 100,000 animals rushing together, to butcher each other, as men do everywhere?'

Not for nothing is the Vietnam memorial in Washington so different from its flamboyant, patriotic forbears. Instead of eagles and rifles there are only stark slabs of black marble with the names of the American dead engraved on them. As Michael Mandelbaum has observed, "represents the soldier not as hero but as an innocent and faceless victim."

Putin and Bush, the soul-mates, are throwbacks to a bygone age. As long as they both remain in power the peoples of the world are stymied from making further progress to discard war- an ambition that only a few years ago a majority seemed set on.



Copyright © 2004 By JONATHAN POWER


I can be reached by phone +44 7785 351172 and e-mail:




Follow this link to read about - and order - Jonathan Power's book written for the

40th Anniversary of Amnesty International

"Like Water on Stone - The Story of Amnesty International"




Här kan du läsa om - och köpa - Jonathan Powers bok på svenska

"Som Droppen Urholkar Stenen"



Tell a friend about this article

Send to:


Message and your name






S P E C I A L S & F O R U M S

Iraq Forum

Gandhi & India

Burundi Forum

Photo galleries

Nonviolence Forum

TFF News Navigator

Become a TFF Friend

TFF Online Bookstore

Reconciliation project

EU conflict-management

Make an online donation

Foundation update and more

TFF Peace Training Network

Make a donation via bank or postal giro

Basic menu below












The Transnational Foundation for Peace and Future Research
Vegagatan 25, S - 224 57 Lund, Sweden
Phone + 46 - 46 - 145909     Fax + 46 - 46 - 144512

© TFF 1997-2004